Author: * Heraklia Aelius -
1 Post
on this thread out of
7,379 Posts
sitewide.
Date: Mar 10, 2004 - 11:22
Any study of ancient women must focus
on two problems: only male historians and writers speak for them,
and those men are focused single-mindedly on the ruling class of Hellas and its dependencies. The “short and simple annals of the poor” have
little or no place in historical analysis before the 19th century.
References to women must be analyzed to understand, and sometimes
discount, the male perspective that produced them. Much is known
about the women of upper class Athens and very little about their humbler sisters. Both are encompassed in a society that viewed women almost solely in terms of their sexual and reproductive functions and that allowed them no more personal freedom than many repressive eastern cultures today.
Women in Classical Greece
A necessary perspective on understanding classical female society in the ancient world is evident in studying how the Greeks viewed a woman's place; a perspective that had untold influence on later cultures. And that cultural norm, in many ways, was to treat the women of ancient Greece as children.
"She was not yet fifteen years old when
she came to me, and up to that time she had lived in leading-strings,
seeing, hearing and saying as little as possible. If when she came
she knew no more than how, when given wool, to turn out a cloak,
and had seen only how the spinning is given out to the maids, is
not that as much as could be expected? For in control of her appetite,
Socrates, she had been excellently trained..." Xenophon,
On Men and Women,from Oikonomikos, c. 370 BC.
In the sixth-century Athens of Pericles, a
strongly male-dominated culture relegated women to a position of
essential impotence beyond the bonds of their children and households.
Greek women were, legally and figuratively, considered as children
all their lives. Societal mores separated male and female activities
in every sphere. Women and their children lived in separate quarters
in their fathers’ or husband’s house. Literacy was not encouraged
for respectable women. A woman’s major - almost sole - function
was to produce a legitimate heir; thus she sought marriage above
all other goals, usually marrying in her early 'teens, often to
much-older men. Her chastity and reputation were paramount. A respectable
woman was not expected to escape the confines of her father or husband’s
house; the less she was seen or even mentioned by other men, the
more her honor. She was not permitted to eat in the company of males
except those from her own family (only prostitutes, or hetairai,
dined with strange men). Friendship between men (including homosexual
friendship) was considered far nobler and more spiritually satisfying
than any love a husband might hold for his wife. Socrates could
and did dismiss his wife, Xanthippe, from his deathbed, preferring
to die with his male companions; the decision was viewed with approval.
All the great Greek playwrights included women
in dramatic or comic scenes (although, of course, only male actors
could portray them). Only in comedy was a woman's assertiveness
considered humorous, like the angry wives in Lysistrata who
refuse their husbands sex and child care to force the vote for peace.
In tragedies, an assertive woman usually spelled disaster; in a
case such as Medea's, a woman's natural jealousy and tempestuous
emotional instability resulted in the murder of her own children.
|
| |
" All the long time the
war has lasted, we have endured in modest silence
all you men did; you never allowed us to open our
lips. We were far from satisfied, for we knew how
things were going; often in our homes we would hear
you discussing, upside down and inside out, some important
turn of affairs. Then with sad hearts, but smiling
lips, we would ask you: Well, in today's Assembly
did they vote peace?-But, "Mind your own business!"
the husband would growl, "Hold your tongue, please!"
And we would say no more. …But presently I would come
to know you had arrived at some fresh decision more
fatally foolish than ever. "Ah! my dear man," I would
say, "what madness next!" But he would only look at
me askance and say: "Just weave your web, please;
else your cheeks will smart for hours. War is men's
business!" "
|
|
| |
Aristophanes,
Lysistrata. |
|
|
|
Except
for religious ceremonies, women were not permitted to mix with men
in public, attend political gatherings or the theater, or vote.
An Athenian woman was not allowed to make important social or financial
decisions without a male guardian’s consent and had little or no
financial independence. Although the Athenian male came of age at
18, an Athenian woman never did; her legal status until her death
remained that of a minor child. She was provided little or no formal
education other than necessary household wisdom. It was considered
inappropriate for a woman to go to market without chaperones. Societal
strictures and law firmly enforced the ideal that a woman was inferior
to her morally superior husband, required his guidance, and must
submit to his wisdom. Aristotle wrote that marriage between men
and women is inherently unequal, and that a woman must look to her
husband as a beneficiary looks to a benefactor. His influence was
wide-ranging. Only lower-class women, who had to work to help sustain
the household, escaped some of these strictures.
Yet there were exceptions to the outlines sketched
above. Perhaps one of the most famous and influential women in Athens
was the extraordinary Aspasia,
mistress of the statesman Pericles, friend of Socrates. It is sufficient
to say that her reputation for learning, wit, and political influence
was allowed partly because she was only a resident alien in Athens
(thus free from restrictions on Athenian women) and because she
was a hetaira. It is a peculiar fact that Greek prostitutes
were permitted infinitely more intellectual freedom than their chaste
sisters, free to dine, learn, and argue philosophy with men beyond
their other professional accomplishments.
The
city-state of Sparta deviated from some of these restrictive conventions
but its influence was minor compared to that of Athens and Athens’
influence on its numerous colonies abroad. Although some of the
more severe Greek strictures against women relaxed in the Hellenistic
period, Greek women remained bound by moral dependency, lack of
financial independence and lack of education throughout antiquity.
Interestingly, many traditions of the Greeks were absorbed in the
later, Byzantine culture. In antiquity, Greeks colonized towns in
Sicily and southern Italy: Greek cultural stereotypes concerning
women were influential even into the development of Imperial Rome.
SOURCES: I drew this from the research necessary for my web site, Feminae Romanae: The Women of Ancient Rome, and it's bibliography, here.
|