Author: * Sementawy Horemheb -
5 Posts
on this thread out of
1,092 Posts
sitewide.
Date: Mar 24, 2008 - 10:28
Asenath, you said in your post of February the 5th that you didn't 'mind constructive criticism if it's delivered in a fair manner.'
In regards to us all 'having the guts' to call a halt to posting and responding to the mockups, the tentative cut of date for posting mockups was February the 1st (with the date extended to February 9th, just in case)... and you have since then posted three or so more mockups. No-one was that ridged and the date came and went and no-one, not me, not even you took any notice whatsoever.
You write, 'No-one seems to be happy with anything' but look back over the previous posts! Look at all those compliments on your work! Every one of them, well deserved.
February saw the scribes of Meritities, Mereneith and Seshats unavoidably away. No-one could call a halt at the time. I was not a scribe at that time, however, your mockup posted on Janaury the 28th got my vote on January the 29th. The ones you posted since the cut off date have great merit. They are beautifully executed and either one of them would suit perfectly! They speaks volumes on your talent. I prefer the stone mockup with Nefertari (?) but since it was posted after the closing date(s) should we disregard it? No, we shouldn't, because it's gorgeous.
I for one welcome keeping this going for a week or more yet. So, I'll stand up and make the decision...
Everyone is invited to post their final mockups for the main Egyptian page no later than midnight AW time of Sunday March 31st.
Voting will commence on April the 2nd.
Asenath, if you have any more mockups to share with us, please do so - don't hide away!
|